Please Help Us Keep These Thousands of Blog Posts Growing and Free for All

$5.00

The Misguided Question of a “Caused” God

The familiar challenge “Who made God?” arises frequently, as though it were a decisive blow against belief in a Creator. Even the atheist philosopher Bertrand Russell once declared, “If everything must have a cause, then God must have a cause.” Yet this question fundamentally misrepresents what theists actually claim. The argument for a Creator is not that “everything that exists has a cause,” but rather “everything that begins to exist has a cause.” This means an Uncaused Cause is perfectly coherent. If God is eternal and did not begin to exist at any point in time, then it is unnecessary to posit a cause for Him.

Scripture offers clarity on the eternal nature of God. Psalm 90:1-2 states: “Jehovah, you have been our dwelling place in all generations. Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever you had formed the earth and the world, from everlasting to everlasting you are God.” According to those words, God’s existence stretches infinitely into the past and unendingly into the future. It is not that He emerged from nothing. He has always been. The prophet Isaiah asked rhetorically, “Have you not known? Have you not heard? Jehovah is the everlasting God, the Creator of the ends of the earth. He does not faint or grow weary; his understanding is unsearchable.” (Isaiah 40:28) This same truth rings out in Revelation 1:8, where God identifies Himself as the Alpha and Omega, the One who is and who was and who is to come, the Almighty. These texts underscore that God is uncreated and independent of anything else in existence.

Scientific Support for a Beginning

Many skeptics of God’s uncaused existence hold to the idea that everything must have a cause. Yet modern cosmology consistently affirms that the universe itself had a beginning. Scientists point to the second law of thermodynamics, showing that energy tends to move from a state of concentration to a state of diffusion. If the universe had existed for an infinite amount of time, it would have already reached a state of heat death—an absolute equilibrium where no life or processes could continue. The fact that we have not reached that equilibrium indicates the universe has not existed forever.

In addition, empirical observations of the universe’s expansion suggest that all of space, time, and matter originated from a singular state. This implies that matter, energy, and even the laws of physics did not exist at some point in the distant past. These findings align well with Genesis 1:1, which declares, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.” Our vast, constantly expanding cosmos is not self-existent. Its features and laws point to a definitive beginning—something that modern scientific study acknowledges, albeit often without ascribing it to a personal Creator. Yet the question remains: Could an uncaused universe exist forever, or did it require an eternal Being outside of it? Christians maintain with certainty that an eternal, personal, all-powerful God brought it into existence.

The Creator Beyond Physical Reality

If matter, space, and time all came into being together, then the ultimate cause of the universe must be independent of matter, space, and time. As the Uncaused Cause, God is not subject to the limitations and laws that apply to the created realm. Skeptics sometimes ask, “Why does God not need a cause?” The answer is that God, by definition, never began to exist. Things that begin to exist require a cause; something that exists eternally does not. The logic is straightforward: if an entity is uncaused and eternal, it does not fall under the principle “Whatever begins to exist has a cause.” It is not special pleading; it is simply acknowledging that an eternal Being has no starting point.

Scripture confirms that God transcends physical reality. Psalm 94:9 poses the question: “He who planted the ear, does he not hear? He who formed the eye, does he not see?” The verse conveys that the One who created our powers and senses must possess the capacity for those powers in a superior way. When we read, “Jehovah is the everlasting God,” (Isaiah 40:28), it highlights the truth that God is beyond the confines of the natural world. This frees us from the error of thinking that all reality must be purely physical and subject to physical causation. If something or Someone brought matter, time, and space into existence, that One could not be bound by time or space.

Why the Universe Cannot Be Uncaused

For centuries, it was assumed by many philosophers that the universe itself might be eternal and self-existing. The ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, for instance, theorized an eternal cosmos without a personal, creating God behind it. Much later, numerous thinkers tried to resurrect the notion of an eternal universe, arguing that the cosmos could be the “uncaused cause.” Modern science has challenged this premise. The standard cosmological model reveals that the universe has a finite age—an actual beginning. If it began at a certain point, it must have had a sufficient reason or cause. Atheists who previously embraced the idea of a self-existent universe find themselves having to explain why a cause is required for everything except a hypothetical eternal cosmos. Now that the universe is known to have a starting point, the real question surfaces: What caused it to come into being?

A cause must be powerful enough to account for everything in the cosmos, from the largest galaxies to the tiniest subatomic particles. It must be fundamentally different from the universe itself in order to bring it into existence, like an artist who is separate from the canvas on which he paints. Scripture echoes this idea of a God who precedes and surpasses His creation. Revelation 4:11 extols the Almighty: “Worthy are you, our Lord and God, to receive glory and honor and power, for you created all things, and by your will they existed and were created.” The cause of the universe cannot be within the universe; it has to stand outside. The biblical God fits that description perfectly.

Logical Realities That Do Not Begin

Some might argue that God must require a cause because “everything needs a cause.” But various realities exist without a beginning. We can consider the laws of logic, such as the law of identity (“X = X”), which govern rational thought. Love and justice are moral truths that do not appear to be conjured out of thin air at some point in time. From a Christian vantage point, these qualities derive eternally from the character of God. They did not begin. A skeptic might believe these concepts are mere abstractions or products of human minds, but that position does not fully explain their unchanging, universal nature. If logic and morality were products of human invention, they would vary wildly and would not serve as universal standards. Yet we treat them as absolutes, indicating that these realities are rooted in an eternal source—God. They did not “come into existence,” and they do not “go out of existence.”

Similarly, the concept of an eternally existing Being is not contradictory. It is no more illogical than the idea that the universe once existed without cause, which many people long believed. Now that modern evidence points to a beginning of the cosmos, the claim that an infinite chain of events existed in the past has fallen out of favor. Yet the question “Who made God?” tries to press God into the same category as everything that begins to exist. This is a category mistake. It is akin to asking, “How does the color green taste?” or “How many minutes are there in the concept of justice?” An uncaused entity, by definition, is not subject to the question “Who caused it?” If it were, it would not be uncaused.

Scriptural Support for an Eternal Creator

The Bible consistently teaches that God is eternal, without origin. Moses wrote: “Jehovah, you have been our dwelling place in all generations. Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever you had formed the earth and the world, from everlasting to everlasting you are God.” (Psalm 90:1-2) The prophet Isaiah declared: “Have you not known? Have you not heard? Jehovah is the everlasting God.” (Isaiah 40:28) The New Testament underscores this same truth. Jude 25 refers to God as “the only God, our Savior, through Jesus Christ our Lord, be glory, majesty, dominion, and authority, before all time and now and forever.”

These passages reaffirm that God has always been. There is no reference to an external power shaping or bringing Him forth. That is why Paul could write, “Now to the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only God, be honor and glory forever and ever. Amen.” (1 Timothy 1:17) He also calls God “the eternal King,” acknowledging that He is unique in His beginningless existence. This is precisely the answer to the question “Who made God?” It is not that God once sprang out of nonexistence, but rather that He has no origin. From a historical standpoint, believers have always held this position. The Scriptures have been declaring it for thousands of years, whether in the psalms of David, the oracles of Isaiah, the letters of Paul, or the Revelation of John.

Category Mistakes and the Nature of God

Asking “Who made God?” implies He belongs to the same category as created entities that began to exist. The question tries to impose a property of created things—needing a cause—onto the Uncreated Being. It demands a cause for the One who transcends causation. Some critics claim that if we exempt God from the need for a cause, we are guilty of special pleading. However, it is no more special pleading than claiming the laws of logic never began to exist. We distinguish between that which is eternal and that which is temporal. We do not conclude that absolutely everything is caused. We conclude that everything that begins to exist must be caused. Since God never began, He is not subject to that rule.

If we rephrase the question “Who made God?” into “What caused the self-existent, uncaused Cause to exist?” the fallacy is exposed. The question becomes self-contradictory. A self-existent being does not need an outside agent. If another being had caused God, we would merely push the question back another step, leading to the ultimate cause. According to Scripture, the “ultimate cause” is God Himself, who is the final explanation for all created reality.

The Logic of the Uncaused Cause

Some might charge that the notion of an uncaused God is too big a leap. David Hume, who was skeptical of religion, called it “absurd” to think that something could emerge without cause. Indeed, believers agree that “nothing comes from nothing.” Yet God never “came” from anything. He always was. This does not violate logic or science. The principle “Whatever begins to exist has a cause” presupposes something starting. God, existing timelessly before creation, was never in a state of nonexistence. Since He never began to exist, the causal principle does not apply to Him.

Moreover, we do not see something or someone “popping into existence from nothing” today. Observing cosmic expansion or the second law of thermodynamics points us to the reality that the universe had a definite origin. This origin cannot be from “nothing,” if “nothing” literally means the absence of all potential, energy, or power. Being cannot come from nonbeing. There must be an eternal, uncaused source. Scripture affirms that the eternal One spoke the universe into existence. (Psalm 33:6) His word was sufficient to bring forth matter, life, and laws that govern the cosmos.

The Bible’s Answer to “Who Made God?”

The Scriptures offer direct insight. Psalm 90:1-2 calls God the dwelling place of His people “from everlasting to everlasting.” This poetic language underscores that God has no starting point. Isaiah 40:28 calls Him “the everlasting God, the Creator of the ends of the earth.” Jude 25 ascribes praise “before all time and now and forever.” The apostle John in Revelation 4:11 speaks of God as the One “who created all things, and by his will they existed and were created.” Revelation 1:8 reveals God as the timeless Alpha and Omega. None of these passages admit a more fundamental cause or a more powerful God that brought Him about. Instead, He is consistently portrayed as self-existent and supremely sovereign.

One might wonder why humans struggle to comprehend this. Psalm 90:4 reminds us that God’s sense of time differs from our own: “A thousand years in your sight are but as yesterday when it is past, or as a watch in the night.” (Compare 2 Peter 3:8.) For finite creatures, everything has a beginning. We are born, we watch others grow old, and we see them die. Our brief lifespan now clouds our capacity to fathom an eternal Being. The analogy of a tiny insect with a 28-day lifespan helps illustrate how difficult it would be for that insect to grasp 100 years of human life or 200 years of a giant tortoise’s life. Our position before God is even more limited.

God Before Creation

Genesis 1:1 famously declares, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.” Before that “beginning,” there was only God. Job 38:4, 7 references a time when the morning stars, or angels, “shouted for joy” at the creation of the earth. Thus, angels already existed when God laid the foundations of the world. Yet angels are themselves created beings (Psalm 148:2, 5). That means there was a timeless state in which God existed all alone—before matter, before space, before angels, and before humans. He was not idle; He simply had not yet created. This underscores that God’s choice to create was not forced upon Him by any external necessity. It was an act flowing from His own will and purpose. No outside power nudged Him to create.

This helps explain why the question “Who made God?” has no footing. As soon as one admits there must be some ultimate cause behind all existence, that ultimate cause cannot itself be an effect. If there were an even higher cause behind God, that would be the real God. Instead, the Bible proclaims that Jehovah is the Most High, uncreated and everlasting. (Psalm 83:18) He requires no cause because He never began.

The Universe Testifies to an Eternal God

Romans 1:20 testifies that creation itself offers evidence of God’s eternal power and divine nature. When we stand under a clear night sky, we behold the spectacle of countless stars. Galaxies shine with unimaginable brilliance. The order and complexity we see in life—DNA, intricate biological systems, and the cosmic fine-tuning—attest to an intelligence behind it all. These wonders align with the biblical position that an infinite, personal Creator conceived the universe, set its laws in motion, and established life on earth.

God’s existence from eternity assures us that He did not rely on anything outside Himself. This is part of what makes Him God. In Psalm 94:12, we observe that those privileged to receive God’s instruction can recognize the right path in a creation filled with wonders. Psalm 100:3 reminds us, “He made us, and we are his,” according to a literal rendering. We did not create ourselves, nor did we appear out of nothing. We come from an eternal source with the power to craft life in all its beauty.

Human Limitations and God’s Boundlessness

It is natural to find eternal existence perplexing. Our minds are wired to perceive beginnings and endings, and everything around us in nature adheres to finite parameters. From the perspective of a being who lives for only a few decades, living forever—let alone having always existed—feels foreign. Yet Scripture cautions against the assumption that our human perspective is the ultimate standard. Isaiah 55:8-9 states: “‘My thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways,’ declares Jehovah. ‘For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts.’” God’s infinite nature is not expected to be fully grasped by finite minds. This is not an appeal to mystery for the sake of ignorance; it is an acknowledgment that limited creatures cannot exhaustively comprehend the unlimited.

Consider that if Adam and Eve had remained faithful, they and their immediate descendants might be vastly older than we are now, potentially able to better appreciate the idea of an eternal being. Sin introduced death into the world. (Romans 5:12) Consequently, humans currently lack the lifespans or mental vantage that might deepen our understanding of a God who spans eternity. Yet even our brief experience of life can point us to the reality that we inhabit a creation so finely tuned and purposeful that it must reflect an all-powerful, timeless Author.

The Eternal God and Life’s Difficulties

Some question, “If God is eternal and good, why do we see hardships in life?” Scripture clarifies that God does not cause evil to refine or test us, nor does He entice us toward wrongdoing. James 1:13 affirms, “God cannot be tempted by evil, and he himself tempts no one.” Humans undergo difficulties because of living outside of God’s sovereign rule, going all the way back to the first rebellion in Eden. Even though we experience pain and suffering, this does not undermine God’s eternal nature. Rather, our mortal perspective can deepen our desire to comprehend His timeless purposes. It reminds us that we exist in a temporary condition, whereas He has no such constraint.

From the vantage point of an everlasting God, even centuries of human history are brief. Our suffering is not essential to God’s plan. It is a demonstration of what occurs when we attempt to live independently of Him. The present condition of the world highlights that moral and spiritual laws—grounded in God’s character—cannot be broken without serious consequences. As Psalm 94:2 indicates, those who arrogantly overstep God’s boundaries face eventual judgment. They bring misery upon themselves and others, which does not originate from divine intention, but from their own rebellion against the way of life God established.

Logical Coherence of God’s Self-Existence

When skeptics assert, “But everything must have a cause,” they are presupposing that only physical, finite things exist. Yet if only finite things exist, we cannot explain the absolute beginning of space, time, and matter. Nor can we account for eternal laws of logic and morality. Some may claim that these laws emerge from material processes in the brain, but that does not explain their unchanging universal nature, which extends beyond individual minds. The belief in an eternal Mind, namely God, resolves the problem of grounding these invariant truths.

Further, it is consistent to maintain that the cosmos, which had a temporal beginning, must be contingent and caused, while the Creator, who did not begin, is therefore uncaused. This distinction stands on solid philosophical footing and is reinforced by the teachings of Scripture. If we deny an Uncaused Cause, we end up stuck in an infinite regress of causes or an unscientific claim that something appeared from sheer nothing. As David Hume acknowledged, it is logically impossible to get being from absolute nonbeing.

Eternal Existence and Biblical Chronology

Believers who affirm God’s eternal nature also take note of literal Biblical chronology in events such as the Exodus in 1446 B.C.E. and the destruction of Jerusalem in 587 B.C.E. These historical markers are woven into Scripture to show that God engages in real time and with real nations, without diminishing His eternal attributes. He can enter our temporal realm, act decisively, and still remain the timeless Creator. Far from being some distant, static force, He is the self-existent One who shapes human history and redeems humanity according to His plan.

For example, the call of Moses to lead Israel out of Egypt in 1446 B.C.E. was an intervention of this eternal God at a specific point in time. He displayed His power over Pharaoh and the gods of Egypt, none of which could match His might. Similarly, when Jerusalem fell in 587 B.C.E., it fulfilled prophetic warnings issued by the same God. The unfolding of events in biblical history demonstrates His sovereignty in the realm of space-time. Yet none of these interventions imply that God has any origin in time.

The Uniqueness of the Uncreated Creator

There can be only one eternal God who is infinite in power and wisdom. If there were two such infinite beings, they would not be two. They would merge into one, for nothing could distinguish them in their absolute qualities. Thus, Scripture can boldly proclaim that there is only one Almighty. (Isaiah 46:9) This uniqueness is part of why worship rightfully belongs to God alone. He needs nothing from us, for He is the source of all existence. (Psalm 50:10-12) Yet He graciously allows His creatures to worship Him and receive His love and truth.

At times, people attempt to place God in the same category as pagan deities or angels. But these are mere created beings. The Bible is explicit that all other so-called gods do not measure up to the eternal Creator. Psalm 96:4 reminds us: “Jehovah is great, and greatly to be praised; he is to be feared above all gods.” Pagan deities or idols had origins in human imaginations or demonic influences, but Jehovah alone precedes every dimension of reality, both seen and unseen. His existence does not arise from any prior cause, and He is not an exalted creature among lesser creatures. Instead, He is alone in His self-existence.

Grasping the Eternal King

The apostle Paul’s doxology in 1 Timothy 1:17 expresses an awe-filled exclamation: “To the King of the ages, incorruptible, invisible, the only God, be honor and glory forever and ever. Amen.” Ancient Hebrew writers depicted God as the One “who sits above the circle of the earth,” (Isaiah 40:22) emphasizing His exalted vantage. Like children staring upward, we try to see the entire sky, but it extends far beyond our view. That is how God’s eternal nature is. We cannot see the beginning or the end of it because there is none.

Rather than finding this exasperating or contradictory, believers see it as a glorious truth. We are comforted by a God who is not contingent, frail, or threatened. He is the bedrock of reality. Jude 25 says, “To the only God, our Savior, through Jesus Christ our Lord, be glory, majesty, dominion, and authority, before all time and now and forever.” This eternal dimension of God is why the question “Who made God?” has never been a stumbling block for those who understand the Scriptural portrayal of the Almighty.

The Housefly Analogy and Human Limitations

If a housefly, living for just 28 days, could form thoughts about time, it might struggle to accept a turtle’s 200-year lifespan as possible. It knows only 28 days, so the concept of 200 years is staggering. The gap between us and a fly is small compared to the gap between the eternal Creator and His creation. It should not surprise us that the finite mind struggles to grasp infinity. Yet the difficulty of conceiving something does not determine its truth or falsity. Many realities in science and mathematics are counterintuitive to our everyday experiences, yet we accept them once the evidence is compelling.

In the same way, the biblical record, affirmed by logical reasoning and supported by the testimony of the created order, points to God as the eternal, unmade Maker of all. Our struggles with that concept reveal our own limitations, not any defect in the idea that a timeless God exists. Indeed, such a Being is the only way to ground the reality we see and the laws we rely upon for coherent thought. Our short lifespans and finite perspectives cannot define the boundaries of what is real.

The Unchanging Foundation of All Reality

Psalm 102:25-27 paints a striking picture of God’s eternality: “Of old you laid the foundation of the earth, and the heavens are the work of your hands. They will perish, but you will endure; all of them will wear out like a garment. You change them like clothing, and they pass away, but you are the same, and your years have no end.” The universe can shift, stars can burn out, galaxies can collide, but God remains unaltered. Hebrews 1:10-12 cites this same passage and applies it to the supremacy of God’s nature, indicating that creation is not self-existent or permanent. Only God is. This concept underscores again why “Who made God?” is a categorical error: the question fails to distinguish between that which is changeable and created and the eternal, unchanging source of all.

Resolving the Skeptic’s Objection

When skeptics contend that God must have a cause if everything else does, they often unwittingly assume that physical existence is all there is. They might concede that the universe had a beginning but reject the conclusion that an eternal God caused it. Some propose that the universe caused itself. Yet something non-existent cannot bring itself into existence, since it does not exist to do the causing. We must look elsewhere to find the reason for the universe’s origin. The Bible’s declaration of an eternal God who speaks creation into existence stands as the most coherent explanation available.

Modern thinkers sometimes claim that quantum mechanics allows “virtual particles” to appear spontaneously without cause. Yet these so-called vacuum fluctuations happen within the framework of established physical laws, energy fields, and a pre-existing space-time vacuum. It is not “nothing.” It is a sea of energy governed by known rules. God, by contrast, requires no external framework. He is self-existent. Romans 11:36 elegantly summarizes this: “From him and through him and to him are all things. To him be glory forever. Amen.”

God’s Eternity and Human Purpose

Acknowledging an eternal Creator leads naturally to the question of purpose. If God always existed, and He created humanity in His image (Genesis 1:26-27), what was His intent? Scripture answers that God made humans to reflect His love, wisdom, and righteousness. (Ephesians 4:24) We were not produced by accident or cosmic chance; we are the handiwork of a God with an eternal plan. While sin disrupted that original design, the Creator did not abandon His purpose. He provided hope of redemption. (Romans 6:23) Even as we exist in a world marred by sin and death, we can look forward to a restored relationship with our Maker.

Psalm 100:3 confidently asserts, “Know that Jehovah, he is God! It is he who made us, and we are his.” That direct confession should shape our perspective. We are His creations, dependent upon His sustaining power. Colossians 1:17 declares that in Him “all things hold together.” That includes the laws of nature and the moral order underpinning human society. Recognizing this fosters a sense of reverence. We live in a universe instituted by an everlasting Mind. We do not define or sustain reality; we discover it and live within its parameters. Neglecting these truths leads to confusion. Embracing them opens the way to wisdom.

Concluding Reflections

The question “If God made the universe, who made God?” rests on a misconception of what the Bible teaches and what logic demands. An eternal Being does not require an origin. An uncaused Cause transcends the principle of causation that applies to finite, temporal objects. Those who find it difficult to accept this often do so because they assume everything is material or because they cannot conceive of an eternal dimension. Yet neither of those objections dislodges the biblical portrayal of God as the One who always was and always will be.

By studying the universe, we find compelling evidence of a beginning in space, time, and matter. The notion that something could come from absolute nonexistence is untenable. The best explanation is that an eternal, non-physical Cause brought the universe into being. Scripture identifies that Cause as Jehovah, the everlasting God, who formed the earth and the mountains and created life. His existence from all eternity is not an evasion. It is the only anchor that makes sense of reality as we know it. As Psalm 93:2 states, “Your throne is established from of old; you are from everlasting.” There is no power that shaped God. He is the One who shapes all else.

Thus, “Who made God?” is the wrong question to begin with. It treats the Uncreated Being as a created thing. The biblical answer is that God was never made. He is “from everlasting to everlasting,” the foundation of all that exists, the One “in whom we live and move and have our being.” (Acts 17:28) Humanity’s calling is to recognize that truth and respond in genuine trust and gratitude. We owe our very existence to Him whose life had no beginning. He alone is worthy of praise, for all creation rests upon His eternal majesty.

You May Also Enjoy

How Can We Understand Docetism’s Challenge to the Humanity of Jesus?

About the Author

EDWARD D. ANDREWS (AS in Criminal Justice, BS in Religion, MA in Biblical Studies, and MDiv in Theology) is CEO and President of Christian Publishing House. He has authored over 220+ books. In addition, Andrews is the Chief Translator of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV).