Paul calls congregational oversight a fine work and immediately explains what sort of man may undertake it (1 Timothy 3:1–7). His instructions concern the people entrusted to the overseer as well as the man who seeks the responsibility. The congregation needs a shepherd who can teach the truth, govern his own conduct, and care for people whose spiritual welfare is at stake. The question of women in the pastorate belongs within that larger discussion because Paul addresses teaching and authority over men just before describing the qualified overseer. His letter to Titus gives corresponding qualifications for appointing elders and also charges mature Christian women with teaching that is essential to the life of the congregation (Titus 1:5–9; Titus 2:3–5). Each responsibility has to be understood from what Paul assigns, to whom he assigns it, and why he gives the instruction.

The Work of an Elder, Overseer, and Shepherd

Paul left Titus in Crete to put deficient matters in order and appoint elders in city after city (Titus 1:5). He begins by describing the man eligible for appointment and then explains that an overseer must be above reproach because he is God’s steward (Titus 1:6–7). The reason Paul gives for the overseer’s conduct applies directly to the elder Titus is to appoint. The same relationship appears when Paul summons the elders of Ephesus and charges those men as overseers to shepherd the congregation (Acts 20:17, 28). Elder identifies the man in his appointed responsibility, overseer describes his charge, and shepherding describes the work he does for those under his care. A congregation evaluating a pastoral appointment must therefore examine what the person will actually do, including whether the person will exercise oversight and teach the congregation. A change in the title of the position leaves the nature of that work intact.

Learning, Teaching, and Authority in 1 Timothy

Paul’s first instruction in 1 Timothy 2:11 is that a woman learn. He directs that she learn “in silence with full submissiveness” (UASV), describing the manner in which she receives instruction. The Greek noun hēsychia can denote quietness, and its use here is tied first to learning and then to the contrast Paul draws with teaching and exercising authority. The instruction expects Christian women to know what they believe and to grow in their understanding of Scripture. That expectation has practical consequences for a congregation, since women need access to serious biblical instruction if they are to explain their faith, recognize error, and teach those entrusted to their care. Paul begins with a positive duty, and a church that treats women’s study of Scripture as incidental neglects the first thing he tells them to do in the passage.

Paul continues, “But I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man, but to be in silence” (1 Timothy 2:12, UASV). The sentence coordinates teaching and exercising authority, and both activities are placed under the prohibition in the congregational setting. Reading the verse as a ban solely on domineering behavior leaves the prohibition concerning teaching unexplained. Peter already forbids elders themselves to domineer over those in their care, so the congregation must distinguish the eligibility to exercise oversight from the manner in which an overseer exercises it (1 Peter 5:2–3). Paul proceeds to require that the overseer be able to teach and describes him in male household terms (1 Timothy 3:2–5). A woman therefore may not serve as pastor or overseer or take on the congregation’s authoritative teaching responsibility over men under another title. The restriction has a defined setting, and that setting matters when reading passages in which women instruct others.

Why Paul Appeals to Adam and Eve

Paul introduces his reason with the words “For Adam was formed first, then Eve” (1 Timothy 2:13, UASV). The appeal reaches back to the creation account, where Jehovah formed the man and then made the woman (Genesis 2:7, 18–23). Timothy was in Ephesus to confront false teaching, and that local situation explains the urgency of many of the letter’s instructions (1 Timothy 1:3–7). Paul nevertheless gives the order of creation as his reason here, so an explanation limited to local conditions leaves his stated reasoning unaccounted for. He also recalls that Eve was deceived and came into transgression (1 Timothy 2:14). This is a reference to what happened in Eden, where Adam remained responsible for his own disobedience and Jehovah held him accountable for it (Genesis 3:17–19). Paul likewise traces the entrance of sin into the world through Adam in Romans 5:12, which prevents the reference to Eve from being made into an excuse for Adam or a claim about the judgment of every woman.

Paul’s reference to childbearing must be read with the condition he gives in the same sentence. After speaking in the singular, he writes in the plural of continuing in faith, love, holiness, and self-control (1 Timothy 2:15). That continuation governs how the promise is understood, and childbearing cannot be treated as an act that earns salvation. Paul has already identified Christ Jesus as the one mediator who gave Himself as a ransom (1 Timothy 2:5–6). In the context of Adam and Eve, the reference honors the place of childbearing in the life of women for whom motherhood is a responsibility, while the condition identifies the Christian conduct in which women are to continue. Paul elsewhere recognizes faithful unmarried service to the Lord (1 Corinthians 7:34–35). A congregation therefore has reason to honor motherhood and the faithful service of women who have never borne children.

The Character Required of an Overseer

Paul’s statement that a man desires a fine work when he reaches out for oversight is followed by the words “The overseer must be above reproach” (1 Timothy 3:1–2, UASV). Above reproach describes a man whose conduct gives no valid ground for a discrediting charge. As the husband of one wife, he must be faithful in his marriage, and the qualification requires sexual integrity in the man considered for office. The phrase describes marital fidelity and gives the congregation grounds to examine a candidate’s conduct toward his wife if he is married. He must be temperate, sober-minded, respectable, hospitable, and able to teach (1 Timothy 3:2). These qualities are visible in the way he controls his appetites, weighs decisions, conducts himself, receives people, and helps them understand Scripture. Hospitality can be seen when he makes time and room for people who need encouragement, including those from whom he can expect no return. Ability to teach becomes evident when he can explain a passage accurately enough for hearers to see how its wording supports what he says.

Paul also specifies habits that would make a man unsafe or unfit for oversight. He must be free from drunkenness, reasonable in his dealings, and neither quarrelsome nor given to fighting, and he must be free from the love of money (1 Timothy 3:3). Titus adds that the overseer must neither be self-willed nor quick-tempered, must be free from violence and drunkenness, and must have no appetite for dishonest gain (Titus 1:7). Self-will and quick temper become apparent when a man treats a reasonable question as defiance or presses for his own way before hearing others. His attitude toward money can become apparent when a decision involves his own financial interest. Titus also requires him to be hospitable, a lover of what is good, sound in mind, righteous, loyal, and self-controlled (Titus 1:8). A man’s treatment of a person who can offer him no advantage gives evidence of whether he loves what is good and acts justly in ordinary dealings.

Household Conduct, Maturity, and Public Reputation

The candidate’s household gives the congregation a place to look for evidence of his ability to care for people. Paul requires him to manage his own household well, keeping his children in subjection with all seriousness (1 Timothy 3:4). He then asks how a man who does not know how to manage his own household will take care of the congregation of God (1 Timothy 3:5). Titus likewise requires a man above reproach, the husband of one wife, with children who believe and are free from accusations of debauchery or rebelliousness (Titus 1:6). The two letters direct attention to the conduct visible in the home, where a man’s responsibilities are sustained over time. Where a candidate has children under his care, the congregation can consider how he teaches them, responds to wrongdoing, and maintains order with seriousness. A public ability to speak about Christian family life gives the congregation only part of the evidence it needs.

An overseer must also be sufficiently established in the faith and have a good reputation among those outside the congregation (1 Timothy 3:6–7). Paul excludes the newly converted man because rapid elevation can make him conceited and bring him into judgment. The danger is concrete when a man has received public praise for his ability to speak but has had little opportunity to show how he receives correction or handles responsibility among believers. The requirement of a good reputation outside the congregation also calls for evidence from ordinary life. People who deal with the candidate at work or in business may know whether he keeps his word or takes advantage of others when he can. Paul links that reputation to avoiding reproach and the Devil’s snare, so a congregation has reason to take substantiated concerns about a candidate’s public conduct seriously.

Teaching Sound Doctrine and Refuting Error

Titus 1:9 explains why an overseer must hold firmly to the faithful word in accordance with the teaching he received. He must be able both to encourage by sound doctrine and to refute those who contradict it. Paul immediately describes deceptive teachers who were upsetting whole households for dishonest gain (Titus 1:10–11). The situation shows why the overseer needs more than fluency in speaking. When a false claim is circulating, he has to identify what is being taught, explain the relevant passage accurately, and show the people affected why the claim fails. His responsibility to encourage also requires him to help believers understand what the truth gives them grounds to believe and do. The same commitment to the faithful word governs the elder when he comforts a discouraged person and when he corrects a persuasive teacher.

The Teaching Entrusted to Mature Christian Women

Paul addresses the conduct and teaching of older women as part of what accords with sound doctrine (Titus 2:1, 3–5). They are to be reverent in behavior, refrain from slander, avoid enslavement to much wine, and teach what is good. Their conduct bears directly on their fitness to give that instruction. A woman who refuses to repeat damaging talk about another household can teach restraint with the credibility of someone who practices it. Paul gives the teaching a purpose when he directs older women to encourage younger women to love their husbands and children, to be self-controlled and pure, to work at home, to be kind, and to submit to their own husbands. The instruction is intended to shape conduct within the household so that the word of God is not spoken of abusively.

The teaching Paul assigns to older women can address situations that require sustained attention and personal example. A younger mother who wants to correct a child without losing her temper can learn from a mature Christian woman how self-control and kindness govern her words while she gives needed correction. An older woman can also help a younger wife understand why Paul says to submit to her own husband, keeping the instruction tied to the marriage relationship Paul names. Scripture gives other examples of women using their knowledge to serve others. Priscilla and Aquila took Apollos aside and explained the way of God more accurately to him, and Paul remembers the sincere faith of Timothy’s grandmother Lois and his mother Eunice alongside his account of Timothy’s knowledge of Scripture from infancy (Acts 18:24–26; 2 Timothy 1:5; 2 Timothy 3:14–15). The congregation has concrete work to support when mature women teach younger women and help children grow in knowledge of the Scriptures.

You May Also Enjoy

What Kind of Church Would Jesus or Paul Attend Today?

About the Author

CLICK LINKED IMAGE TO VISIT ONLINE STORE

CLICK TO SCROLL THROUGH OUR BOOKS