Please Help Us Keep These Thousands of Blog Posts Growing and Free for All
The above YouTube video by a Christian, Bill Dyer, of Southern Evangelical Seminary is very misinforming and should be discussed. Below I will interact with his video and share with you my insights. I highly suggest that you also watch his video. First, let’s start by defining Critical Race Theory (CRT).
CRITICAL RACE THEORY: What is on the outside is what makes you who you are.
THE BIBLE: The inner person is what makes you who you are.
Critical Race Theory (CRT) is an academic movement made up of civil-rights scholars and activists in the United States who seek to critically examine the law as it intersects with issues of race and to challenge mainstream liberal approaches to racial justice. CRT examines social and cultural issues as they relate to race, law, and social and political power. This is the basic argument for CRT that is written so as to seem like it is reasonable and rational. ‘However, the truth of CRT is that it is an essential or basic element of a larger philosophical movement that sees American principles as a lie, covering for mere racist power dynamics. It’s destructive and directed at tearing down the country.’ (Ben Shapiro)
In September 2020, President Donald Trump issued an executive order directing agencies of the United States Government to cancel funding for programs that mention “white privilege” or “critical race theory,” on the basis that it constituted “divisive, un-American propaganda.” He specifically called out the value of meritocracy. On January 20, 2021, President Joe Biden issued an executive order rescinding and canceling Trump’s previous executive order and once again permitted agencies to use such programs.
Interacting with the YouTube Video
When Bill Dyer says, “I totally reject CRT,” and then says, “but,” he just negated his statement. Also, social justice is just as damaging to humanity as CRT. No one that rejects CRT said that they did not want to hear from minorities as Dyer infers. This is a strawman argument* fallacy. Dyer is rationalizing. For example, BLM is a domestic terror group. So, it would be like you saying, “I don’t support BLM because it is a domestic terror group, but I do believe black lives matter.” Yes, that goes without saying. But singling out races is also to divide people among races, causing division, the very thing both philosophies (CRT & BLM) are supposed to be against. I think Dyer is failing to understand that these people are leftist Marxists who do not have the beliefs and values he thinks they do, and they will spin their message to get their desired outcome. Dyer is rationalizing and helping their cause, whether he realizes it or not. The very title of his YouTube post is misplaced. “Why Critical Race Theory is Important.” It is not important. In a nutshell, once more, CRT is an essential or basic element of a larger philosophical movement that sees American principles as a lie, covering for mere racist power dynamics. It’s destructive and directed at tearing down the country. Anything else is rationalizing, justifying, minimizing from people such as Dyer.
* STRAWMAN ARGUMENT: A straw man (sometimes written as strawman) is a form of argument and an informal fallacy of having the impression of refuting an argument, whereas the proper idea of the argument under discussion was not addressed or properly refuted. One who engages in this fallacy is said to be “attacking a straw man.“
When Dyer says you should not be scared, I ask who said they were sacred? This is another strawman fallacy. Who said they are not willing to listen to the struggles of minorities? No one, we do it all the time. But the struggles of minorities have nothing to do with the philosophies of or mindset of CRT and their end goal. Dyer offers his listeners one strawman fallacy after another. He says, ‘we can reject CRT and still say the American system is not perfect.’ Who said the American system was perfect? Dyer is setting up false arguments that no one made and then knocking them down, trying to appear like he is making rational points. No one said America was without flaws. I would be interested in knowing what liberal school Dyer went to because that is becoming self-evident. Who said we could not criticize the bad things that happened in America? Who has some idealized thinking about America that is unrealistic? Who said America does everything perfectly? Who said that the American system does not have room for improvement?
It is not as difficult as Dyer suggests these days for anyone in America to get out of any cycle. This is a myth. All one needs is determination and the desire to do so regardless of their circumstances. There are far more whites in cycles and dire straits than blacks, so this idea of white privilege is a farce. Even if a person was not given love and life skills from their parents, it is still very possible to get those on their own through themselves or other sources. For young persons you have (1) other relatives, (2) school counselors, (3) pastors, (4) government programs, (5) books, and (6) friends, to mentions just a few options.
When Dyer says the books he read have defined CRT and Dyer will give us those tenants, it is an illusion. The supports of CRT will give their readers and listeners winsome words, good-sounding talking points, and trivial or superficial arguments. It is what the CRT proponents say on social media and how they act that will dictate their actual beliefs and motives. I think Dyer is confusing philosophy with worldviews. But I will let that go. Yes, Dyer is correct; people are not calm about this. Dyer should extend his research to watching some videos where the leftist Marxists are talking about CRT in their volatile ways, and then watch the conservatives calmly discuss it. Also, look at the BLM and Antifa groups in the summer of 2020, where they destroyed America to the tune of billions, killing over 30 people. These are the most prominent advocates of CRT. So, Dyer is leaving out who are the ones who are not calm and this is a bit disingenuous.
After having spoken with Bill Dyer on the phone, he explained again what he had said in the above video. More is coming on this subject matter where he intends to let the people know just how dangerous CRT is and the damage it will cause if it goes unchecked. He explained his process in this first video as trying to soften things, so as to get the left to the table to discuss matters. I explained that I knew that was what he was trying to do but that his video was still ambiguous, not that informative for an 18-minute video, and his failure to define who the people are when he says, “some people think this or some people think that.” In addition, the continual strawman arguments do not help if you do not know who the people are that are making these claims that Dyer speaks of. Lastly, what happens to those who do not come back for the following videos.
 Josh Dawsey; Jeff Stein, (5 September 2020). “White House directs federal agencies to cancel race-related training sessions it calls ‘un-American propaganda.’” The Washington Post. Retrieved Monday, March 15, 2021.
“Executive Order on Combating Race and Sex Stereotyping.” White House. 2020 September 22.
Cady Lang, (29 September 2020). “What Is Critical Race Theory?”. Time.
 President Joe Biden rescinds Donald Trump ban on diversity training about systemic racism