Peter: Following Jesus Despite His Sense of Unworthiness

Please Help Us Keep These Thousands of Blog Posts Growing and Free for All

$5.00

When Jesus Entered Peter’s Ordinary Work

Peter’s call in Luke 5 begins not in a synagogue, palace, or theological school but beside the lake where he earned his living as a fisherman. Luke 5:1-3 records Jesus entering Simon’s boat and using it as a place from which to teach the crowds gathered along the shore. When Jesus finished speaking, He told Simon to put out into deep water and lower the nets for a catch. Peter answered that they had worked throughout the night and caught nothing, a statement reflecting the judgment of an experienced fisherman who knew the discouragement of unsuccessful labor. Yet he added, “at your word I will let down the nets,” according to Luke 5:5. That response reveals the beginning of courageous discipleship because Peter acted upon Jesus’ word when his professional experience gave him no reason to expect success. Faith did not require Peter to deny that the night had been fruitless; it required him to give Jesus’ word greater authority than the discouraging result of the previous hours. Courage often begins at exactly that point, where obedience moves forward despite strong personal reasons for believing another attempt is pointless.

The resulting catch overwhelmed Peter’s expectations because Luke 5:6-7 states that the fishermen enclosed so many fish that the nets began breaking and both boats became so full that they started sinking. Peter’s reaction is striking because he did not first celebrate the economic value of the catch or congratulate himself for having followed instructions. Luke 5:8 records him falling at Jesus’ knees and saying, “Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord.” The extraordinary event made Peter more conscious of his own unworthiness in the presence of Jesus’ authority. This sense of sinfulness contained truth because Peter was an imperfect man, and Scripture never teaches that a disciple should regard himself as morally equal to Christ. Romans 3:23 later states that all have sinned and fall short of God’s glory, while Hebrews 4:15 identifies Jesus as without sin. The danger arises only when awareness of unworthiness becomes a reason to move away from the One who calls sinners to follow Him. Peter wanted distance, but Jesus answered by giving him a future assignment.

“Do Not Be Afraid”

Jesus’ answer to Peter in Luke 5:10 directly addresses the fear created by Peter’s sense of sinfulness: “Do not be afraid; from now on you will be catching men.” Jesus did not tell Peter that his self-assessment was entirely mistaken or that sin did not matter. Instead, He removed fear as the governing response and redirected Peter toward discipleship and ministry. Luke 5:11 states that Peter and his companions brought the boats to land, left everything, and followed Jesus. The huge catch that had just demonstrated Jesus’ authority did not become the reason Peter stayed in fishing to pursue greater profit. He left the very occupation in which the miracle had produced extraordinary abundance because following Jesus now had greater value than the material result lying in the boats. Matthew 6:33 later expresses the priority of seeking the kingdom and God’s righteousness first. Courageous discipleship therefore requires more than admitting that Jesus is powerful; it requires rearranging life in response to His authority.

Peter’s experience corrects a common misuse of humility in which a person says, in effect, “I am too flawed for Jehovah to use me, so I will do nothing.” Scripture certainly requires Christians to recognize sin, repent, and avoid self-exaltation, but it never treats obedient inactivity as the proper expression of humility when Christ has given a responsibility. Matthew 28:19-20 commands disciples to participate in making disciples, while Hebrews 10:24-25 requires believers to encourage one another and remain actively connected with Christian worship. 1 Peter 4:10 later instructs Christians to use whatever gift they have received in serving one another, showing that Peter himself learned to connect humility with responsible service. Genuine humility says that the strength, message, and authority belong to God while still accepting the work He assigns. False humility keeps the attention centered upon self by making personal inadequacy more decisive than God’s command. Peter had to learn that Jesus knew his weaknesses more thoroughly than Peter knew them and still told him to follow. Courage therefore meant trusting Jesus’ judgment about the assignment more than trusting his own impulse to withdraw.

Peter’s Courage Was Real but Uneven

The Gospels do not flatten Peter into either a hero or a failure because his courage developed through both strong actions and painful mistakes. Matthew 14:28-31 records Peter asking Jesus to command him to come across the water, stepping out of the boat, and then becoming frightened when he focused on the wind. His willingness to leave the boat was courageous, but his fear revealed how quickly courage could weaken when attention shifted from Jesus’ command to threatening circumstances. Matthew 16:16 records Peter boldly identifying Jesus as the Christ, the Son of the living God, yet only a short time later Peter resisted Jesus’ teaching concerning His coming suffering. Matthew 26:33-35 records Peter insisting that he would never stumble even if all the others did, demonstrating sincere loyalty mixed with overconfidence concerning his own strength. These episodes teach that courage must be governed by truth rather than temperament. A naturally impulsive person can perform daring actions and still lack the steadiness required for enduring faithfulness. Proverbs 28:26 warns against trusting one’s own heart, directing believers toward wisdom rather than self-confidence.

Peter’s failure on the night of Jesus’ arrest provides the sharpest example. Although he had promised extraordinary loyalty, Matthew 26:69-75 records him denying three times that he knew Jesus. The pressure did not come from a formal execution sentence pronounced against Peter at that moment but from people identifying him as one of Jesus’ associates. When the rooster crowed, Peter remembered Jesus’ words and went outside and wept bitterly. His tears demonstrate that the denial did not reflect settled rejection of Christ but a devastating collapse under fear. Luke 22:31-32 records that Jesus had already warned Peter of the coming spiritual assault and told him that after he returned he should strengthen his brothers. Jesus therefore knew Peter would fail and also knew failure would not be the final chapter of Peter’s discipleship. Courage after failure requires repentance strong enough to return rather than shame strong enough to disappear.

Jesus Did Not Define Peter by His Worst Moment

After Jesus’ resurrection, John 21 returns Peter to a fishing setting that deliberately places him again before the Lord who had first called him beside the lake. The disciples had caught nothing during the night, and the resurrected Jesus instructed them to cast the net on the right side of the boat, producing another extraordinary catch. When Peter recognized that the man on shore was Jesus, he threw himself into the sea and hurried toward Him, behavior very different from the earlier request that Jesus depart from him. John 21:15-17 records Jesus asking Peter three times about his love and then assigning him responsibility for feeding and tending His sheep. The threefold questioning confronted Peter personally without permanently disqualifying him for his threefold denial. Jesus did not minimize the failure, but neither did He allow Peter’s worst night to become the final definition of his usefulness. Repentance restored Peter to active responsibility rather than merely relieving guilty emotion. Christians therefore learn that courageous recovery requires accepting Christ’s correction and returning to faithful service.

Jesus then told Peter that his future discipleship would ultimately include a death by which he would glorify God, according to John 21:18-19. After speaking about that future, Jesus repeated the same essential command that had governed Peter’s discipleship from the beginning: “Follow Me!” Peter then looked toward the beloved disciple and asked what would happen to him. Jesus answered that whatever He willed for the other disciple was not Peter’s concern and said again, “You follow me,” as recorded in John 21:20-22. Peter therefore had to learn courage without comparison. Following Jesus would not become easier by knowing whether another disciple received a longer life, a different assignment, less suffering, or greater visible prominence. Galatians 6:4-5 later instructs each person to examine his own work and carry his own responsibility rather than constructing identity through comparison with others. Courage becomes steadier when the disciple asks what Christ requires of him rather than why another servant’s path differs.

From Fearful Denial to Public Witness

The book of Acts demonstrates how profoundly Peter matured after the resurrection and Pentecost. Acts 2 records him publicly explaining the Scriptural meaning of what had occurred and openly proclaiming Jesus’ resurrection and exaltation before a large Jerusalem audience. Acts 3 records him continuing public witness, while Acts 4 places Peter and John before rulers, elders, and scribes who demanded an explanation for their teaching. Peter, guided by the Spirit-inspired truth he had received, identified Jesus Christ as the One whom the authorities had executed and whom God had raised from the dead. When ordered to stop speaking in Jesus’ name, Peter and John answered in Acts 4:19-20 that obedience to what they had seen and heard could not be surrendered to human commands. Acts 5:29 later gives the principle even more directly: “We must obey God rather than men.” The man who once denied Jesus in a courtyard under social pressure now stood before organized authority and refused to stop preaching. Courage had become stronger because Peter had learned not to trust his own promises but to depend upon the truth Christ had taught him.

Peter’s later letters show the same development in his counsel to other Christians. 1 Peter 3:14-15 tells believers not to fear what opponents fear but to sanctify Christ as Lord in their hearts and remain ready to make a defense before anyone who asks for a reason for their hope. 1 Peter 5:8-9 warns that the Devil walks about like a roaring lion seeking someone to devour and therefore commands Christians to resist him, firm in the faith. These words come from a man who knew personally what fear, overconfidence, failure, repentance, restoration, and renewed courage looked like. Peter did not teach a form of courage based on pretending that spiritual danger is imaginary. He warned Christians to stay alert precisely because opposition from Satan and the wicked world is real. Ephesians 6:11-12 likewise describes the believer’s struggle against wicked spirit forces and commands the use of the full armor of God. Christian courage is therefore watchful, Scriptural, humble, and resistant rather than boastful.

Following Jesus While Remaining Conscious of Grace

Peter never needed to forget that he was an imperfect man in order to follow Jesus courageously. His first response beside the lake, “I am a sinful man,” contained an awareness that remained appropriate throughout his life when properly governed by faith. 1 Peter 5:5 later tells Christians to clothe themselves with humility, demonstrating that maturity did not turn Peter into a self-exalting leader who forgot his dependence upon God. At the same time, humility no longer drove him away from responsibility because Jesus had repeatedly shown him that service was not reserved for people who had never failed. Peter learned to repent, receive correction, strengthen others, preach publicly, care for fellow Christians, resist intimidation, and keep following. Philippians 3:13-14 expresses a related principle in Paul’s determination to press forward rather than allow the past to halt present obedience. Christians likewise must distinguish remembering past lessons from living as permanent prisoners of past failures. Courage accepts Jehovah’s forgiveness on Scriptural grounds and then performs the responsibilities His Word continues to require.

The command “Follow Me” therefore summarizes Peter’s entire journey from unworthiness to useful courage. He followed when Jesus’ word contradicted a fruitless night of fishing, followed when discipleship required leaving livelihood behind, followed imperfectly through moments of fear, returned after denial, and followed again when Jesus told him that faithfulness would eventually cost his life. His courage was not the absence of weakness but the repeated decision to return to Christ’s direction after weakness became visible. Luke 22:32 shows Jesus telling Peter that after turning back he must strengthen his brothers, demonstrating that lessons learned through failure can equip a repentant Christian to help others remain faithful. Christians should therefore neither glorify failure nor imagine that failure places every repentant believer beyond future usefulness. The governing question is whether the person returns to Scripture, abandons the wrong conduct, accepts correction, and resumes obedient discipleship. Peter’s life answers his first fearful statement beside the lake: the sinner does not need to tell Jesus to depart when Jesus is calling him to follow. Courage begins by believing Christ’s command more strongly than one’s sense of inadequacy and continues by following Him wherever obedience leads.

You May Also Enjoy

The Widow of Zarephath: Acting in Faith During Famine and Grief

About the Author

EDWARD D. ANDREWS (AS in Criminal Justice, BS in Religion, MA in Biblical Studies, and MDiv in Theology) is CEO and President of Christian Publishing House. He has authored over 220+ books. In addition, Andrews is the Chief Translator of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV).

CLICK LINKED IMAGE TO VISIT ONLINE STORE

CLICK TO SCROLL THROUGH OUR BOOKS

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Discover more from Christian Publishing House Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading