Why Has God Allowed Bad Things to Happen When He Has the Power to Stop Them?

Please Help Us Keep These Thousands of Blog Posts Growing and Free for All

$5.00

A Biblical Defense of God’s Sovereignty and Permission of Evil (Genesis 3:1-6, 23-24)

Introduction: The Problem of Evil and Misunderstood Assumptions

The question of why an all-powerful, loving God allows suffering, evil, and disaster has been a major stumbling block for many skeptics and even some professing believers. As voiced by Bart D. Ehrman and others, the issue seems to pit God’s power and goodness against the reality of human suffering, leading some to conclude that either God is not all-powerful, not good, or perhaps non-existent. However, such conclusions arise from a fundamental misreading of Scripture and a failure to grasp the moral and theological framework that the Bible provides. The error lies in starting with false assumptions, particularly the notion that God is directly responsible for every action or that His love requires the immediate prevention of all suffering.

The correct starting point is the biblical record itself, particularly the events described in Genesis 3:1-6, 23-24 and the book of Job. These texts provide the essential context for understanding why bad things happen and why God permits them for a time, though He has the power to stop them.

The Genesis Account: The Origin of Human Suffering and Evil

Genesis 3:1-6 provides the historical account of the first human rebellion against God’s command. Jehovah had clearly warned Adam at Genesis 2:17, “but from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat from it you shall surely die.” This divine prohibition was simple, direct, and understandable. The tree itself symbolized the right to decide what is good and bad—something reserved exclusively for the Creator.

In Genesis 3:1-5, Satan, operating through the serpent, challenges God’s statement and accuses Him of lying and withholding good from His creation. The serpent claims, “You will not surely die. For God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.” This direct contradiction of Jehovah’s word was not just a lie; it was an open challenge against God’s sovereignty and integrity.

The issue was not merely that Adam and Eve ate a piece of fruit. The true issue was a challenge to God’s rightful authority, sovereignty, and truthfulness. By eating from the tree, Adam and Eve asserted their supposed right to determine good and evil independently of their Creator, thereby rejecting divine guidance. The sin was not ignorance, but willful rebellion.

The Challenge to Divine Sovereignty

This rebellion raised critical moral questions that needed resolution:

Was Jehovah’s rulership truly just and loving?
Could humans rightly govern themselves apart from divine guidance?
Would obedience to God exist only when circumstances were favorable?
Was God withholding good from His creation?

Satan’s accusations called into question not the power of God (which Satan never challenged) but His right to rule and the justice of His rule. If God had immediately destroyed Adam, Eve, and Satan, the moral issues raised would remain unresolved in the minds of the observing angelic realm and future human generations. Instant annihilation would not demonstrate why self-rule leads to failure, nor would it prove that God’s sovereignty is inherently righteous.

The analogy of a slandered father explains this dynamic well. If a father is accused of abuse and the children are said to obey only out of fear or selfish gain, violently silencing the accuser would only confirm suspicion. The way to disprove such slander is to allow time for the children to prove their genuine love and loyalty by their free choice, not by compulsion.

The Role of Free Will and Moral Agency

The Bible teaches that both angels and humans were created with free will, the ability to choose between obedience and disobedience. Without this freedom, love and loyalty would be meaningless. For love to be real, it must be freely given, not forced. This principle explains why God did not program humans and angels to obey automatically.

Deuteronomy 30:19 states, “I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse. Therefore, choose life so that you and your descendants may live.” Choice implies the possibility of disobedience, but it also makes true love and obedience meaningful.

The permission of evil, then, is not a failure of God’s power or love but the necessary consequence of granting free will. To remove the possibility of wrong choice would be to remove freedom itself.

The Book of Job: The Universal Application of the Issue

The account of Job provides further clarification. In Job 1:6-11 and 2:4-5, Satan again challenges human loyalty, asserting that Job’s obedience is purely transactional—that Job serves God only because he benefits materially. Jehovah allows Satan to test Job within limits, not because God is cruel, but because the issue of whether humans will remain faithful under trial needed to be settled.

This challenge reflects the larger cosmic question: Are God’s creatures loyal out of love or merely out of self-interest? The testing of Job and the patience of God in allowing time to resolve these questions are consistent with the issues raised in Eden.

Indirect vs. Direct Responsibility

A critical distinction must be made between direct and indirect responsibility. While God is the Creator and therefore the ultimate Source of life, He is not the author of sin, nor does He directly cause evil acts. James 1:13 makes this clear: “Let no one say when he is tempted, ‘I am being tempted by God,’ for God cannot be tempted by evil, and he himself tempts no one.”

When tragedy strikes, such as natural disasters or human cruelty, it is not because God actively willed these evils. Rather, these are often the consequences of human choices, the corrupted condition of the natural world, or, in some cases, the influence of Satan, who is identified as “the god of this world” (2 Corinthians 4:4) and “the ruler of the authority of the air” (Ephesians 2:2).

This does not mean that God is powerless to intervene, but that His decision not to intervene immediately is part of a larger, morally sufficient plan to resolve these challenges decisively and permanently.

Why Not Stop It Earlier?

The question remains: Why has God allowed evil and suffering to persist for thousands of years?

The answer lies in the nature of the moral demonstration being conducted. If God had intervened prematurely—say, before human governments had fully displayed their failure, or before humans had exhausted every form of rulership—the argument could always be made that given more time, success might have been possible. As Proverbs 1:30-31 expresses, those who reject God’s counsel will “eat the fruit of their way and be sated with their own devices.”

Human history under Satan’s influence has now thoroughly demonstrated the results of rejecting divine rulership. No form of human government, no philosophy, no system has succeeded in bringing lasting peace, justice, or happiness.

This process is not about satisfying human curiosity or merely proving a point for its own sake. It is about securing the moral foundation of God’s rule for eternity. Once the issues are resolved, the lesson will stand forever as a precedent, ensuring that the same rebellion never arises again.

The Future Resolution: God’s Appointed Time

The Bible assures that the permission of evil is temporary. Acts 17:31 affirms, “because he has set a day on which he is going to judge the inhabited earth in righteousness by a man whom he appointed.” This “appointed time” corresponds with the eschatological judgment described in Revelation 11:18, where God will “destroy those who are destroying the earth.”

Daniel 11:27 reinforces the concept of a fixed, divine timetable: “for the end is still to come at the appointed time.” God has not been passive. He has set in motion a plan that will culminate in the vindication of His sovereignty and the permanent removal of evil.

Why Was Satan Not Immediately Cast Out?

Satan retained access to the heavenly realm for a time after the rebellion in Eden. However, Revelation 12:9-12 describes a future event in which Satan is cast down to the earth, signaling the approaching end of his influence. The text states, “the devil has come down to you with great wrath, because he knows that his time is short.” This casting out occurs shortly before the Great Tribulation and the establishment of God’s kingdom rule through Christ.

The delay in removing Satan was not due to weakness on God’s part but was part of the process of exposing Satan’s failure as a ruler and deceiver. Had Satan been immediately destroyed, the charges he raised would have remained untested in the minds of other free moral agents, human and angelic.

Conclusion: Vindicating God’s Sovereignty and Justice

The permission of evil is not evidence against God’s existence, power, or goodness. Rather, it is a necessary part of resolving the moral issues raised by Satan’s rebellion. The suffering of the present world testifies not to divine failure but to human failure apart from God.

Jehovah’s patience is not abandonment but mercy, providing time for all who wish to respond rightly. As 2 Peter 3:9 says, “Jehovah is not slow concerning his promise, as some regard slowness, but is patient toward you, because he does not wish for any to perish but for all to come to repentance.”

The lesson of human history under Satan’s dominion will stand forever as a clear demonstration that independence from the Creator brings ruin, while submission to God brings life and peace.

Please Help Us Keep These Thousands of Blog Posts Growing and Free for All

$5.00

You May Also Enjoy

What Are Some Proven Ways to Handle Bible Difficulties?

About the Author

EDWARD D. ANDREWS (AS in Criminal Justice, BS in Religion, MA in Biblical Studies, and MDiv in Theology) is CEO and President of Christian Publishing House. He has authored over 220+ books. In addition, Andrews is the Chief Translator of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV).