The Meaning of Tithing in the Old Testament

The Bible uses the word tithe to refer to a tenth given for a specific purpose connected to worship and covenant life in Israel. Under the old covenant, Jehovah commanded the Israelites to give a tenth of the produce of the land and a tenth of the herd and flock. Deuteronomy 14:22 says, “You shall surely tithe all the produce from what you sow, which comes out of the field every year.” Leviticus 27:30 says that every tenth part of the land and its fruit belonged to Jehovah, and Leviticus 27:32 applies the same principle to the herd and the flock. This was not a vague suggestion but part of the covenant legislation given to Israel. It belonged to the national and religious life of the people living under the Mosaic Law.

The tithe served several functions. Numbers 18:21 explains that the Levites received the tithe because they had no land inheritance like the other tribes and were devoted to service connected with the tabernacle. Then the Levites themselves gave a tenth of that tenth to support the priesthood, according to Numbers 18:26-29. Deuteronomy 14:22-27 also describes a tithe used in connection with worship and sacred celebration before Jehovah, while Deuteronomy 14:28-29 and 26:12 show that in certain years provision was made for the Levite, the foreign resident, the fatherless, and the widow. In other words, Old Testament tithing was not a simplistic “give ten percent to the temple” formula. It was part of a larger covenant structure tied to Israel’s worship, priesthood, land, harvest cycles, and care for those in need.

Tithing Before the Mosaic Law

Some argue that tithing must still bind Christians because Abraham tithed before the Law. It is true that Genesis 14:18-20 records Abram giving a tenth to Melchizedek. It is also true that Jacob vowed in Genesis 28:20-22 to give a tenth to God if Jehovah brought him back in peace. But these passages do not establish a standing universal law for all believers in all ages. Abraham’s act in Genesis 14 appears as a voluntary, specific act after a military victory. The text does not present it as a recurring statute laid on his descendants. Jacob’s statement was a vow, not a command imposed on all worshippers. Therefore, the presence of tithing before Sinai proves that the concept of giving a tenth existed before the Law, but it does not prove that Christians are under a legal requirement to tithe today.

That distinction is essential. Narrative description is not always covenant prescription. Abraham also offered animal sacrifices, but Christians do not continue those offerings because the sacrificial system has been fulfilled and set aside. In the same way, tithing before the Law shows that giving to God has ancient roots, but it does not by itself create a binding Christian ordinance. The New Testament must decide the matter for the church, and when it does, it does not impose the old-covenant tithe on believers.

Why Jesus Mentioned Tithing

Jesus did speak about tithing, but His words must be read in their covenant setting. In Matthew 23:23 He rebuked the scribes and Pharisees because they tithed mint, dill, and cumin while neglecting the weightier matters of the Law: justice, mercy, and faithfulness. He said, “These are the things you should have done without neglecting the others.” Some readers stop there and conclude that Christ affirmed tithing for the church. But Jesus was speaking to Jews living under the Law before His sacrificial death inaugurated the new covenant. He was not laying down a post-resurrection financial code for the Christian congregation. He was condemning hypocrites who carefully observed external requirements while disregarding the moral heart of the Law.

That point is easy to miss if the timeline is ignored. During Jesus’ earthly ministry, the temple still stood, the Levitical priesthood still functioned, and the old covenant had not yet been set aside through His death. Therefore, His affirmation of tithing in Matthew 23:23 was an affirmation of faithfulness within the still-operative old-covenant order. It does not prove that the church, after the cross and resurrection, remains bound to Israel’s tithe system.

What Changed After Christ’s Death

The New Testament teaches that Christians are not under the Mosaic legal code as a covenantal obligation. Colossians 2:13-14 says that the record standing against us was taken out of the way, nailed to the stake. Ephesians 2:15 says that Christ abolished in His flesh the law of commandments in decrees. Hebrews 7:18 speaks of a setting aside of a former commandment because of its weakness and uselessness in bringing perfection. Since the tithe belonged to the covenant structure of Israel, and since that covenant is no longer binding on the Christian congregation, the church is not under a divine command to give a tenth in the old-covenant sense.

This is why the apostolic writings never command Christians to tithe. They speak often about giving, generosity, support for gospel work, care for the poor, and financial responsibility, but they do not reissue the old legal tithe. That silence is significant. If the church had been expected to carry over such a major covenant requirement, the apostles had every opportunity to say so plainly. Instead, they present a different pattern. Christian giving is willing, thoughtful, proportionate, regular, loving, and cheerful, but not legally compelled by the old Israelite tenth. This is the heart of the biblical issue, and it is one reason Tithing – A Case Study is a useful phrase to keep in mind when separating old-covenant law from new-covenant practice.

What the New Testament Commands Instead

The clearest New Testament teaching on Christian giving appears in texts such as 1 Corinthians 16:1-2 and 2 Corinthians 8–9. In 1 Corinthians 16:2, Paul instructs believers to set something aside on the first day of every week in keeping with their prosperity. That means giving is to be regular and proportionate. In 2 Corinthians 9:7 he writes, “Each one must do just as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” That is decisive. Christian giving is not under compulsion. It arises from conviction, gratitude, and love. It is deliberate, not coerced. It is worship, not taxation.

This does not weaken giving. It deepens it. Under the old covenant, the tithe was a legal requirement tied to Israel’s national worship system. Under the new covenant, giving reaches into the heart. The believer gives because he has been transformed by truth and gratitude. He gives to support those who labor in teaching and preaching, as 1 Timothy 5:17-18 indicates. He gives to share with those who instruct him in the Word, as Galatians 6:6 teaches. He gives to meet the needs of fellow believers and others in distress, which is part of Christian mercy and almsgiving. He gives remembering Acts 20:35, that “it is more blessed to give than to receive.” None of that is less serious than the tithe. It is simply governed by a different covenant reality.

How Malachi 3 Should Be Understood

Malachi 3:8-10 is often used to pressure Christians by saying that anyone who does not tithe is robbing God. But the original context is covenant Israel. The prophet addressed people under the Law who were withholding what Jehovah had commanded for the support of the temple order and the priestly system. To lift that text out of its historical setting and place it as a legal threat over the church is poor interpretation. A Christian is not robbing God because he does not submit to an old-covenant statute that is no longer binding as law.

At the same time, the passage still teaches something valuable by way of principle. Jehovah takes worship seriously. He hates stinginess, hypocrisy, and covenant unfaithfulness. He blesses sincere obedience. But this principle must not be twisted into a mechanical formula or into the prosperity gospel, as though a ten-percent payment guarantees financial increase. The New Testament never presents giving as a way to manipulate God into making a person rich. Christian giving is an expression of love, thanksgiving, trust, and obedience. It is not a commercial transaction.

Whether Christians Should Ever Use Ten Percent

A Christian may choose to give ten percent as a personal discipline, and there is nothing wrong with that. A tenth can serve as a wise starting point for some households because it trains generosity and guards against selfishness. But that must remain a matter of personal conviction rather than ecclesiastical law. The moment a church says that every Christian is under divine obligation to give exactly ten percent and that failure to do so places him in disobedience to the new covenant, that church has gone beyond what Scripture says. The apostles did not bind believers in that way, and Christians should not bind one another where the Word of God has left liberty.

The better question for believers is not merely, “Have I reached ten percent?” but, “Am I giving worshipfully, regularly, sacrificially, and cheerfully according to what Jehovah has entrusted to me?” Some poor believers may give less in amount but more in sacrifice. Some wealthy believers may give more than ten percent and still not feel the weight of generosity. The Lord sees the heart, the motive, and the measure of sacrifice. Jesus commended the widow not because she satisfied a mathematical standard, but because she gave from sincere devotion. Christian giving, then, is not a quota system. It is the outworking of a heart trained by Scripture, governed by love, and eager to honor Jehovah with one’s resources.

You May Also Enjoy

How Do God’s Sovereign Rule and Humanity’s Free Will Work Together in Salvation?

About the Author

CLICK LINKED IMAGE TO VISIT ONLINE STORE

CLICK TO SCROLL THROUGH OUR BOOKS