The Bible Does Not Command Christmas, Yet It Does Teach How To Judge Disputed Days

The Bible never commands Christians to celebrate the birth of Jesus on a particular date, and it never describes the early congregations observing an annual nativity festival. That fact should be stated plainly because it helps the discussion remain honest. Christmas is not an obligation imposed by Scripture. At the same time, the Bible provides principles for evaluating voluntary observances and for maintaining unity among Christians who reach different conclusions.

Paul addresses disputed matters where some Christians treat certain days as significant and others do not. “One judges one day as above another; another judges every day alike. Let each one be fully convinced in his own mind.” (Romans 14:5) Paul’s point is not that truth is relative. His point is that some matters are matters of conscience rather than direct command, and Christians must not turn conscience into a weapon.

Therefore the question “Is Christmas a pagan holiday?” must be answered with careful distinctions. Some things are clearly pagan and forbidden, such as worshiping other gods, praying to idols, practicing spiritism, and participating in ceremonies that are acts of devotion to false deities. Other things are cultural forms that may have been used in pagan settings but are not inherently acts of worship. Scripture helps Christians distinguish the two.

Pagan Origin Claims Must Be Separated From Present Meaning And Present Intent

It is historically true that the ancient Roman world included winter festivals in late December and that imperial religion promoted devotion connected with the sun. It is also historically true that, centuries after the apostles, sectors of professed Christianity developed church calendars and chose dates to commemorate events in Jesus’ life, including His birth. Those facts often fuel the claim that Christmas is therefore “pagan.”

Yet the Bible does not teach that an object or a date is permanently defiled because pagans once used something similar. It teaches that idolatry is defilement, and idolatry is defined by worship and devotion, not by a calendar square. A Christian who refuses to honor false gods, refuses pagan rituals, and uses a day to honor God by giving thanks for Christ’s coming into the world is not engaging in pagan worship.

This is where heart intent matters. Intent does not make a sinful act righteous, but it does define whether a disputed cultural practice is being used as worship or merely as a neutral circumstance for giving thanks. Scripture treats the heart as central. “Whatever you do, do all things for the glory of God.” (1 Corinthians 10:31)

Paul’s Meat Market Principle Answers The “Previously Used In Paganism” Argument

The clearest biblical parallel to the Christmas debate is Paul’s discussion of meat associated with idol worship. In the first century, meat sold in the marketplace could have been previously offered in a temple ritual. Some Christians feared that eating such meat would involve them in idolatry. Paul’s answer is direct: idols are nothing, and the meat itself is not spiritually contaminated. “Eat whatever is sold in a meat market, asking no question on account of conscience, for ‘the earth belongs to Jehovah, and everything in it.’” (1 Corinthians 10:25-26)

Paul recognizes a category of spiritually strong Christians who understand that eating meat is not the same thing as worshiping idols. The act is morally neutral when detached from idolatrous devotion. However, Paul also teaches love toward those with tender consciences. If a weaker Christian believes the act is participation in idolatry, and if your exercise of freedom will stumble him, then love restricts freedom. “If food makes my brother stumble, I will never eat meat again.” (1 Corinthians 8:13)

Apply the same reasoning to Christmas. A day, a meal, a family gathering, or a gift is not inherently pagan. If a Christian uses the occasion to thank Jehovah for the sending of His Son, to reflect on the incarnation, and to express generosity and family love without any trace of idolatry, then the act is not pagan worship. Yet if another Christian’s conscience is wounded by participation, love avoids pressuring him. Paul’s point is not “everyone must participate.” His point is “do not crush your brother over disputable matters.”

The Bible Forbids Idolatry, Not Cultural Variety

Scripture’s warnings against paganism are forceful. “Flee from idolatry.” (1 Corinthians 10:14) “You cannot be drinking the cup of Jehovah and the cup of demons.” (1 Corinthians 10:21) These texts forbid participation in worship rites that honor false gods. If a Christmas celebration includes prayers to beings other than Jehovah, spiritualistic symbolism, or practices that are explicitly acts of devotion to another god, then it becomes idolatrous and must be rejected.

But many Christian families do nothing of that kind. They may read the birth accounts in Matthew and Luke, sing hymns that praise God for giving His Son, share a meal, exchange gifts as acts of love, and spend time with family. None of that is inherently pagan. It is simply a family gathering with explicit gratitude to Jehovah.

This distinction also answers a frequent confusion: “But pagans also gave gifts.” Pagans also ate meals. Pagans also lit lamps. Pagans also sang songs. Similarity of form is not identity of worship. Scripture does not teach that Christians must abandon every human practice that pagans ever used. It teaches that Christians must avoid worshiping false gods and must remain morally clean.

Addressing Jeremiah 10 And The Claim That Christmas Trees Are Condemned

A popular argument claims that Jeremiah condemns Christmas trees. Jeremiah 10 describes men who cut a tree, shape it, decorate it with silver and gold, and fasten it so it will not topple. In context, Jeremiah is mocking idol-making. The tree is not a decorative household item; it is carved and treated as an object of worship. The passage contrasts lifeless idols with Jehovah, the living God. The point is idolatry, not seasonal décor.

A Christian who refuses idolatry does not violate Jeremiah 10 by having a decorated tree. If, however, the tree becomes an object of superstition, a good-luck charm, or a substitute devotion that competes with worship of Jehovah, then the Christian has created a problem. Scripture always targets idolatry of the heart, not neutral objects.

When Christmas Becomes Spiritually Dangerous

Although Christmas is not inherently pagan, it can become spiritually dangerous in predictable ways. It becomes dangerous when it trains greed, cultivates envy, pressures families into debt, or becomes a season of drunkenness and immorality. Those are not “pagan origins”; they are sins condemned everywhere in Scripture. It becomes dangerous when it crowds out devotion to Jehovah, replacing worship with consumerism and sentimentality. It becomes dangerous when it introduces religious claims that Scripture does not teach, such as mythical figures treated as morally omniscient, which can confuse children about who truly sees and judges.

These dangers do not require rejecting Christmas as pagan. They require disciplining the celebration according to Scripture. Christians have authority from the Word to reject greed, to practice modesty, to cultivate generosity, and to keep Christ central if they choose to mark the occasion.

Respecting The Conscience Of Those Who Abstain

Some Christians abstain from Christmas precisely because they want to keep worship pure and avoid any association with false religion. That abstention can be an expression of sincere devotion. Scripture protects such conscience. Romans 14 warns against despising one another: “The one who eats must not look down on the one who does not eat, and the one who does not eat must not judge the one who eats.” (Romans 14:3) The same principle applies to special days and celebrations. The abstainer must not declare the participant spiritually corrupt if the participant is not practicing idolatry. The participant must not mock the abstainer as “weak” in a contemptuous sense.

Paul’s instruction is to pursue peace and build one another up. (Romans 14:19) That means a Christian who celebrates Christmas does not campaign aggressively to force others to join. It also means a Christian who abstains does not try to bind his conscience on the whole congregation as if it were Jehovah’s explicit command.

A Bible-Governed Way To Celebrate If One Chooses To Do So

If a Christian chooses to celebrate Christmas, he must do it in a way that honors Jehovah and avoids stumbling others. That includes rejecting any practice that resembles worship of another god, keeping the occasion free from immorality, and using the season as an opportunity to speak about Christ accurately. It also includes humility: the Bible does not command the celebration, so the celebrator cannot treat it as a measure of spirituality.

If a Christian chooses not to celebrate, he must likewise do so in a way that honors Jehovah, without self-righteousness, and with respect for those who disagree. He can still show generosity, hospitality, and love throughout the year without adopting a particular day.

The result is a Scriptural answer: Christmas is not inherently a pagan holiday in the moral sense defined by Scripture. Paganism is idolatrous worship. A Christian can celebrate with clean worship and right intent, and a Christian can abstain for conscience. The Bible’s demand is that both reject idolatry, pursue holiness, and protect unity among the holy ones.

You May Also Enjoy

What Are Boundaries, and Are They Biblical?

About the Author

CLICK LINKED IMAGE TO VISIT ONLINE STORE

CLICK TO SCROLL THROUGH OUR BOOKS